Back to blog
Comparison6 min read

PCSWMM Alternatives for Stormwater Modeling

PCSWMM from CHI, based in Guelph, Canada, is a commercial program built around the EPA SWMM model. People look for an alternative for ordinary reasons: the cost of a seat, a firm that has standardized on Autodesk, a project that needs a different 2D engine, or a need to script the work. This post compares the alternatives we know of. One of them, DrainPilot, is ours, and we say where it falls short. Details are as the vendors listed them in November 2026.

What does PCSWMM do that an alternative has to match?

PCSWMM comes in Professional, Professional 2D and Enterprise editions. CHI lists stand-alone GIS, time series management, hydrologic and hydraulic modeling, decision support tools and integrated 1D-2D modeling, along with training and support. It offers a 30-day trial and an educational grant. Ask CHI for current prices; we could not confirm them from its site.

So an alternative has to answer three questions. Does it use the EPA SWMM engine, or its own? Does it model surface flooding in 2D? And does it give you the GIS and data tools, or do you bring your own?

What is the best alternative to PCSWMM?

It depends on what you are replacing it for. For the same engine at no cost, use EPA SWMM. For large models in an Autodesk firm, look at InfoWorks ICM. For site drainage design, as opposed to network modeling, look at InfoDrainage. For serious 2D flood work, TUFLOW can run SWMM as its 1D engine. For scripting, there is PySWMM. For SWMM in a browser with 2D flooding and calibration on one plan, there is DrainPilot.

ToolDeveloperEngineLicence2D surface flow
PCSWMMCHIEPA SWMM 5Commercial, 30-day trialYes, in Professional 2D
EPA SWMMUS EPAEPA SWMM 5Free, open sourceNo
InfoWorks ICMAutodeskIts own, or EPA SWMM 5CommercialYes
XPSWMMAutodeskModified EPA SWMMContact salesYes
InfoDrainageAutodeskBuilt-in hydraulic analysisSubscription, 30-day trialNot listed
TUFLOWTUFLOWModified EPA SWMM as a 1D optionCommercialYes
PySWMMOpen source projectEPA SWMM 5Open source (BSD)No
DrainPilot (ours)GeoPilot AIEPA SWMM 5.2.4Commercial (Pro plan)Yes, as SWMM objects

Is there a free PCSWMM alternative?

Yes. EPA SWMM is open source and free to use worldwide. Version 5.2.4 models runoff, pipes and channels with kinematic or dynamic wave routing, pollutants, and eight kinds of low impact development control. Its installers are Windows programs, and our guide to running SWMM on a Mac covers the other routes. EPA says a new graphical interface is in development, and that the SWMM-CAT and SSOAP tools are no longer maintained as of March 2025.

What you give up is everything around the engine: GIS tools, a time series manager, calibration search and 2D flooding. If you run a few small models a year, that may not matter. If you build large models from GIS data, the hours add up.

Should you move to InfoWorks ICM?

Consider it if your models are large or your clients use Autodesk. Autodesk says InfoWorks ICM has its own engine, and that since December 2019 it can also run the EPA SWMM 5 engine for users who need it, including where local rules call for a particular engine. It imports SWMM 5 and InfoSWMM models and can export to EPA SWMM format. Autodesk's claim that its own engine is faster and more stable than SWMM comes from the vendor, so test it on your own model.

What happened to XPSWMM and InfoSWMM?

XPSWMM is still on Autodesk's site as an integrated 1D/2D tool for stormwater and wastewater, sold through sales rather than a listed price. Autodesk also points XPSWMM users to an importer that brings their models into InfoWorks ICM. TUFLOW's documentation describes the XPSWMM engine as a modified EPA SWMM that uses TUFLOW for its 2D calculations.

InfoSWMM is a different story. An Autodesk blog from 2023 says it is no longer sold, and Autodesk steers those users to InfoWorks ICM. If you still have a licence, check its status with Autodesk.

Is InfoDrainage the same kind of tool?

Not quite. InfoDrainage is built for designing site drainage: pipes, ponds, swales and sustainable drainage, with Civil 3D integration, templates and reports for local regulations, plus FHWA culvert analysis for US DOT projects. If your job is getting a land development design approved, it may fit better than any SWMM package. If your job is modeling how an existing city network behaves over a long rainfall record, it is probably not what you want.

When does TUFLOW or PySWMM make sense?

TUFLOW suits flood specialists. It added SWMM as a 1D option in 2023, running a modified SWMM alongside its 2D solver, and documents a route for converting XPSWMM models through an exported .inp file. Expect a steeper setup than a SWMM interface.

PySWMM is a Python wrapper around SWMM 5, under a BSD licence. It lets you step through a run, change inflows, write control logic in Python and read output files. It suits research and real-time control studies, and it has no map or interface.

Where does DrainPilot fit?

DrainPilot is our tool. It runs the EPA SWMM 5.2.4 engine in a web browser, opens and saves standard .inp files, and exports the .rpt and .out results. It builds models from survey schedules, DXF drawings and GIS layers, and has auto-calibration against flow and level records, a sensitivity sweep, scenarios, sewer auto-design and cost estimates. It needs a Pro plan, US$$79 a month or US$$790 a year, and there is no free plan.

Its 2D flooding builds the ground out of ordinary SWMM objects, so the engine is still SWMM, and our post on 1D-2D flood modeling in SWMM explains the method and its limits. That is not the same as a dedicated 2D solver such as TUFLOW's.

What it does not have yet:

  • US or UK rainfall. There is no NOAA Atlas 14 or FEH data built in. Design storms come from an IDF curve you enter, by the alternating block method, and SCS and Chicago storms are not offered. You can still bring your own rainfall time series; see how to build a design storm in SWMM.
  • US or UK design checks and reports. Its built-in compliance checks follow India's CPHEEO manuals, and it has no storage sizing or submission report for US or UK reviewers.
  • Large 2D meshes. The browser limit is 20,000 cells.
  • Map projections beyond UTM. A project uses a UTM zone or local drawing units.
  • An AI assistant. PipePilot and PumpPilot have one. DrainPilot does not yet.

How do you check that an alternative agrees with PCSWMM?

If both tools use the EPA SWMM engine, the same .inp file should give very close results, and any gap needs an explanation. Compare peak flows, node depths, flooding volumes and the continuity errors in the report, and check that the engine versions match, because results can shift between SWMM releases. Anything specific to one interface, such as GIS layers or time series links, may not travel in the .inp file. For a tool with a different engine, expect differences and judge them against measured data; our post on SWMM model calibration covers how. Our sister site also has a closer look at PCSWMM vs EPA SWMM.

Try DrainPilot

DrainPilot opens in the browser with nothing to install, and pricing is on one page. Open one of your own .inp files and compare the report with the one you already have.

Share

Jagadeesh Gaddam

CEO, Smart Bhujal

Try this in GeoPilot

Run the analysis described in this article with one prompt. No setup required.

Open GeoPilot

Related posts